THE HOLLYWOOD REPORTER EXEC SUITE MOVIES TV MUSIC TECH THE BUSINESS STYLE CULTURE TRAVEL AWARDS VIDEO BLOGS HEAT VISION BASTARD MACHINE LIVE FEED BEHIND THE SCREEN EARSHOT THE RACE NEWSLETTER NOW NEVER MISS SIGN NEWSLETTERS DAILY EDITION LOGIN GARDNER ABBOTT AND COSTELLO HEIRS APPEAL BROADWAY ROUTINE JOAN MARCUS PRODUCTION STILL PRODUCERS BEAT LAWSUIT FAIR THE HEIRS OWNERSHIP VALID SECOND CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED DISMISSAL COPYRIGHT WILLIAM ABBOTT LOU COSTELLO TONY APPEALS COURT ACCEPT REASON THE LAWSUIT THE 2ND CIRCUIT THE POSSIBILITY LONGER DEMONIC HAND PUPPET BELONGING INTROVERTED STUDENT RELIGIOUS RUN ON ISSUE SCENE CHARACTER MINUTE SKETCH GIRL THE FIFTIES NEW YORK FEDERAL JUDGE REJECTED FINDING EXPLOITATION FAIR USE PLAY CRITIQUE SOCIAL NORMS GOVERNING SMALL TOWN THE BIBLE BELT ENOUGH SECOND CIRCUIT JUDGE REENA RAGGI THE DISTRICT COURT EXPLAIN PURPOSE COPYING NECESSARY FOCUS INQUIRY SIMPLY WHETHER WORK OVERALL MESSAGE COPYRIGHTED MATERIAL OPINION CRITICAL INQUIRY USES ITSELF SING TELL RECITE POEM IMPUNITY THE PLAY GOES ALTERATION THE AUDIENCE RECOGNIZE THE MAIN CHARACTER FALSE CLAIM THE ROUTINE APPEARS THEATRICAL DEVICE LITTLE SIGNIFICANCE APPELLATE JUDGE ABILITY CAPTURE AUDIENCE ATTENTION HAND TO GOD PRODUCER KEVIN MCCOLLUM BE IN TROUBLE ANALYSIS THE CONCLUSION TOO MUCH ADVERSE IMPACT ON LICENSING THE SKETCH THE PRODUCERS SAVED FAILURE COSTELLO THE COMEDY PERFORMED SIGNED UNIVERSAL PICTURES LICENSE NIGHT THE TROPICS VERSION 1945 FILM NAUGHTY NINETIES RENEW UNIVERSAL QUITCLAIMED FILM PROBLEM DEFENDANTS THE RIGHT AUTHORS FOR HIRE MERGED SUPPORT THEORIES READ FULL STRONG LAPSED THE PUBLIC CONCLUSION PARTIES PROTECTED ENTERING DOMAIN INITIAL COPYRIGHT TERM NEED DETERMINE PUBLICATION DIVESTED COMMON LAW COPYRIGHT COMMENTS DISQUS ALL RIGHTS RESERVED TERMS OF USE PRIVACY SITEMAP ABOUT US SUBSCRIBER BACK ISSUES ADVERTISING CONTACT CAREERS INDUSTRY JOBS FOLLOW US TWITTER FIND US FACEBOOK WATCH YOUTUBE AFFILIATE PUBLICATIONS BILLBOARD BACKSTAGE CASTING