PUBLIC EMPLOYEES,RETIREMENT,SYSTEM,OHIO,FINDLAW,LEGAL PROFESSIONAL,VISIT,CONSUMER,SITE,REGISTER,LOGIN,WELCOME,EDIT,YOUR,PROFILE,LOG OUT,JAVASCRIPT,DISABLED,PLEASE,LOG IN,SEARCH,CASES,CODES,PRACTICE MANAGEMENT,JOBS,CAREERS,NEWSLETTERS,BLOGS,LAW,TECHNOLOGY,LAWYER,MARKETING,CORPORATE COUNSEL,STUDENTS,REFERENCE,CASELAW,UNITED STATES,6TH CIR,FONT SIZE,PRINT,UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS,SIXTH CIRCUIT,PLAINTIFF,RICHARD,SCHUMACHER,DEFENDANTS,NOVEMBER 04,NELSON,RYAN,CIRCUIT,JUDGES,DISTRICT JUDGE,BENSON,COLUMBUS OH,JAMES M HARRISON,ASST,GENERAL,OFFICE OF,ATTORNEY GENERAL OF OHIO,JEFFREY S SUTTON,STATE,SOLICITOR,APPEAL,PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION,THE DISTRICT,COURT,THE PUBLIC,EMPLOYEES,EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR,ENACTED,STATUTE,FORFEITURE,CERTAIN,VESTED,PENSION,RIGHTS,FINDING,ABUSE OF DISCRETION,SHALL,AFFIRM,INJUNCTION,JEFFERSON COUNTY,COMMON PLEAS,JUDGE,FROM THE BENCH,IN SEPTEMBER,OCTOBER 1,BENEFITS,ENTITLED,BY LAW,NOTWITHSTANDING,STOOD,CANDIDATE,ELECTION,SEAT,VACATED,OPPOSITION,SALARY,RETURN,THE BENCH,FOR WHAT,STATUTORY,LOOPHOLE,KIND,DOUBLE,IMPOSSIBLE,OHIO LAW,THE OHIO,CODE,PROVISION,READ,PERSON,HOLDING,OFFICE,RETIRE,CHAPTER,DATE,COMMENCEMENT,ALLOWANCE,PERIOD,BEGINNING,THE THIRTY,FIRST DAY,RE ELECTION,TERM OF OFFICE,BEGINS,THE CONSEQUENCE,VIOLATION,OF 3,THE ELECTED,ABLE,PLAN,APPLICATION,FILING,RETIREMENT PLANS,PUBLIC,BALLOT,THIRTY ONE,DAYS,PRIOR,THE ELECTION,ELEVENTH HOUR,PREVENT,LEGISLATURE,SENATE BILL,EFFECTIVE,DECEMBER 6,MONTH,WAS TO,RESUME,JUDICIAL,DUTIES,MORE THAN TWO,MONTHS,BEGUN,COLLECTING,C,LEGISLATION,ELECT,DIVISION,SECTION,APPLY,ELECTIVE,MUNICIPAL,CORPORATION,COUNTY,SUBDIVISION,CODE B,THE REMAINDER,TERM,IMMEDIATELY,COMPENSATION,THE EMPLOYMENT,PERSONS,IN LIGHT,SUSPENDED,JANUARY 1,THE PRESENT,DECLARATORY JUDGMENT,SUIT,THE CONTRACT,CLAUSE,BILL OF ATTAINDER,THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION,CONCLUDING,SUBSTANTIAL,LIKELIHOOD,SUCCESS,CLAIMS,BLOCKING,SUSPENSION,SUBJECT TO,APPELLATE REVIEW,STANDARD,DISTURBED,UNLESS,CLEARLY ERRONEOUS,FINDINGS,FACT,GOVERNING LAW,LEGAL,BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD,BLUE CROSS AND BLUE SHIELD,ASSN,EXERCISING,WITH RESPECT TO,MOTION,DISTRICT COURT,MUST,GIVE,CONSIDERATION,FACTORS,WHETHER,MOVANT,STRONG,SUFFER,IRREPARABLE INJURY,ISSUANCE,CAUSE,HARM,THE PUBLIC INTEREST,ROCK ROLL HALL OF FAME,MUSEUM,GENTILE,DECISIONS,BALANCED,IN RE,MOTOR,REVERSE,DISTRICT COURTS,WEIGHING,BALANCING,EQUITIES,CIRCUMSTANCES,MOLTAN,EAGLE PICHER,INDUS,THE CASE,CIRCUMSTANCE,THE COURT,SAW,CONTRACT CLAUSE,FIND,ADDRESS,THE BILL,ATTAINDER,QUESTION,SEEMS,ASSESSMENT,PREVAIL,ISSUE,PASS,IMPAIRING THE OBLIGATION OF,CONTRACTS,CONST,PROVE,CHANGE,IN STATE,IMPAIRMENT,CONTRACTUAL,RELATIONSHIP,GENERAL MOTORS CORP,CT,QUOTING,ALLIED,STRUCTURAL STEEL,DEMONSTRATION,IN LAW,CONTRACT,HEALTH,ENVIRONMENT,DENIED,OBLIGATION,THE CHANGE,ADJUSTMENT,PARTIES,REASONABLE,THE SERVICE,LEGITIMATE,PUBLIC PURPOSE,VEST,BOARD,THE EFFECT,THE ENGAGEMENT,AUTHORITIES,CONDITIONS,VALID,PENSIONER,VESTED RIGHT,CANNOT,AFTERWARDS,EX REL,TRUSTEES,CLEVELAND POLICE,RELIEF,PENSION FUND,ST 37,FULLY,AS OF,IN OTHER WORDS,CONTRACTUAL RIGHT,RECEIPT,OBVIOUSLY,RIGHT,ARGUE,PRESENT,DISAGREE,CONCEIVABLE,RESIGNING,THE OFFICE,GIVING UP,RELIANCE,ENERGY,GROUP,KANSAS,POWER,LIGHT,CT 69,ATTEMPT,JUSTIFY,REGULATION,JUSTIFIED,IN PASSING,VIABILITY,RETIREMENT FUND,MAINTAINING,CONFIDENCE,FUND,ENDING,ELECTED OFFICIALS,JUDICIARY,LAWYERS,PARTICULAR,WHOSE,PENSIONS,ENACTMENT,UNREASONABLE,SUBMITS,EMERGENCY,MEASURE,ALONE,APPEARS,THE ONLY,ADVANTAGE,THE STATE,PARTY,THE CONTRACTUAL OBLIGATION,COMPLETE,DEFERENCE,LEGISLATIVE,REASONABLENESS,NECESSITY,SELF INTEREST,STAKE,UNITED STATES TRUST,NEW YORK,NEW JERSEY,MOREOVER,FREE,CONSIDER,POLICY,ALTERNATIVES,WE DO,LEGITIMACY,FORWARD,MEAN,NECESSARY,AMBIT,DETERMINED,ADVANCE,HERE,TO NOTHING,PERSUADES,CERTAINTY,CLAIM,COURTS,THE ORDER,AFFIRMED,CASE,THE ROLE,FEDERAL COURTS,SHOULD,PLAY,CONSTITUTIONALITY,PROTECT,INTEGRITY,GOVERNMENTAL,HOLD,CONSTITUTIONAL,AS IT,EVENT,PURPOSE,EXCEPTION,CONTRACTS CLAUSE,AMOUNT,PUNISHMENT,THUS,PROHIBITION AGAINST,BILLS OF ATTAINDER,REACHING,DECISION,EXECUTIVE,BRANCHES,STATE LAW,MAKERS,PUBLIC OFFICIALS,ERODE,BELIEVE,TREAD,ABILITY,CORRECTIVE ACTION,UNDERMINE,PUBLICS,POORLY,CHARACTER,VIOLATED,THE SPIRIT OF THE LAW,IN RESPONSE,ACTED,PRESERVE,CLEAR,TRESPASS,THE FEDERAL,CONSTITUTION,DO NOT,FEDERAL COURT,FACTUAL,SUMMARY,BACKGROUND,ACCURATE,ACCOUNT,PLAINTIFFS,LEADING,UP TO,ACTION,STATE GOVERNMENTS,UNDERSTAND,INTENT,BEHIND,POLITICAL AND LEGISLATIVE,CONTEXT,STATE OF OHIO,ELECTIONS,REELECTION,OFFICIALS,AT THE BEGINNING,SIMULTANEOUSLY,COLLECT,POSITION,PRACTICE,GENERAL ASSEMBLY,THE BEGINNING OF,ORDER,THE VIOLATION OF,ELECTED OFFICE,FORCED,DISCLOSE,PLANS,ENOUGH,ELECTORATE,VOTING,DISCOVERED,POTENTIAL,THE OUTCOME,SEPTEMBER 12,CONSEQUENCES,RETIRING,UPCOMING,RETURNING,THE EXISTENCE,FILED,PETITION,RUN,DELIBERATE,SCHEME,IN CLEAR,THE SPIRIT OF,HINGED,KEEP,SECRET,SEPTEMBER 16,FILING DATE,CANDIDATES,AUGUST 21,LETTER,WANT,AT THIS TIME,SAY PLEASE,SEND,INFORMATION,FISCAL OFFICER,THE SUPREME COURT,HEAR,SUBSEQUENTLY,PERSONNEL,BEGIN,PROCESSING,SEPTEMBER 30,LEARNING,DISCLOSED,GOVERNOR,GEOR