COURT OF APPEAL,DISTRICT,CALIFORNIA,CALIFORNIA CHAMBER OF COMMERCE,PLAINTIFFS,STATE,AIR RESOURCES BOARD,DEFENDANTS,NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF,MANUFACTURERS,INTERVENER,ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FUND,INTERVENERS,MORNING STAR,PACKING,COMPANY,APRIL 06,NIELSEN,GROSS,JAMES R,STEVEN,KURT,CHRISTOPHER,ERIC J,LARRY,DICKE,SIDLEY AUSTIN,SEAN,COMMONS,ROGER,MARTELLA,PAUL,ZIDLICKY,ERIC,PLAINTIFF,THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF,PACIFIC LEGAL FOUNDATION,JAMES S,THEODORE,HADZI,HAROLD,JOHNSON,ANTHONY,FRANCOIS,DALTON,TRUCKING,CONSTRUCTION,ASSOCIATION,MERIT,OIL COMPANY,FARMING,CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY,AIR QUALITY,COALITION,ROBINSON,LOGGERS,ASSOCIATION OF NORTHERN,NORMAN,SKIP BROWN,JOANNE,ROBERT,THE NATIONAL,TAX,COMMITTEE,NATIONAL FEDERATION OF,INDEPENDENT,BUSINESS,SMALL BUSINESS,LEGAL,LUKE,BENBROOK,LAW,GROUP,BRADLEY,STEPHEN,DUVERNAY,ASSOCIATED CALIFORNIA,AMICI CURIAE,BEHALF,KEVIN,JEFFREY,RICHARDS,CALIFORNIA TAXPAYERS,AMICUS CURIAE,ALSTON BIRD,MAUREEN,DAMIEN,TECHNOLOGY,KAMALA D HARRIS,XAVIER BECERRA,ATTORNEYS GENERAL,ROBERT W,SENIOR,ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL,GAVIN,MOLLY,MOSLEY,DEPUTY ATTORNEY GENERAL,DAVID,ROBERT E,ELAINE,BRYANT,CANNON,DEPUTY,CALIFORNIA AIR RESOURCES BOARD,MARY NICHOLS,CAPACITY,CHAIR,BALMES,SANDRA,BERG,JOHN GIOIA,HECTOR DE LA TORRE,EISENHUT,JUDY,RON ROBERTS,PHIL,ALEXANDER,DANIEL SPERLING,OFFICIAL CAPACITIES,MEMBERS OF THE CALIFORNIA,RICHARD,EXECUTIVE OFFICER OF,MIHALY,MATTHEW,CATHERINE,MALINA,NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE,COUNCIL,ERICA,MARTIN,TIMOTHY J,OCONNOR,DONAHUE,GOLDBERG,RESPONDENT,PETTIT,JACKSON,UC BERKELEY SCHOOL OF LAW,BIBER,DALLAS,ECONOMICS,PUBLIC POLICY,SCHOLARS,FRANK G WELLS,ENVIRONMENTAL LAW,CLINIC,UCLA SCHOOL OF LAW,CARA,THE NATURE CONSERVANCY,DIAMOND,NICHOLAS,INTERNATIONAL,EMISSIONS TRADING,CASES,INVOLVE,CALIFORNIA GLOBAL WARMING,ACT OF,THE ACT,HEALTH,CODE,SS 1,ASSEM,BILL,NO 32,SESS,POPULARLY,AB 32,SIMPLE MAJORITY VOTE,LEGISLATIVE,HOUSES,GENERAL PURPOSE,REDUCE,GREENHOUSE GAS,GHG EMISSIONS,PROTECT,ENVIRONMENT,ALLIED,DO NOT,QUARREL,ATTACK,REGULATIONS,THE STATE,BOARD,CAP AND TRADE,PROGRAM,THE AUCTION,GENERALLY,GHGS,MUST,SURRENDER,SUFFICIENT,COMPLIANCE,INSTRUMENTS,OFFSET,CREDITS,COVER,AMOUNT,POLLUTANTS,FACE,MONETARY,NEGATIVE,CONSEQUENCES,TIT,FOR FREE,QUARTERLY,AUCTIONS,ENTITY,CANNOT,BELOW,AUTHORIZED,FREE,PURCHASE,BOARDS,SECONDARY MARKET,SOLD,TRADED,CONTROL,THE TRIAL,COURT,APPEAL,ASSERT,SALES,EXCEED,LEGISLATURES,DELEGATION,AUTHORITY,DESIGN,MARKET BASED,EMISSIONS REDUCTION,SYSTEM,REVENUE,THIRDS,SUPERMAJORITY,VOTE,REQUIREMENT,PROPOSITION 13,CAL CONST,XIII,SS 3,REJECTED,CLAIMS,THOROUGH,WRITTEN,DECISION,QUESTION,HOLD,LEGISLATURE,GAVE,BROAD,THE SCOPE,LEGISLATIVE DELEGATION,RATIFIED,HOW TO,DERIVED,REASONING,EQUATE,SHALL,EXPLAIN,HALLMARKS,NOTHING,PARTICULAR,VALUE,PAYMENT,ITSELF,CONTRARY,VIEW,DRIVEN,JUDGMENTS,WHETHER,BENEFICIAL,AIR POLLUTION,VESTED RIGHT,ONCE,TRADABLE,HOLDER,PRIVILEGE,INDEED,SPECULATORS,BOUGHT,PROFIT,AS ONE,PARTY,PUTS,TAXES,TWIN,PARTICIPATION,THING,FINDING,BULK,THE BRIEFING,THE TEST,DETERMINE,SUBJECT TO,THE KEY,SINCLAIR,PAINT,EQUALIZATION,PROGENY,DETAIL,POST,GOVERNMENTAL,CHARGES,RAISE,THE SYSTEM,COMMODITY,AFFIRM,DENYING,PETITIONS,BACKGROUND,GOVERNOR SCHWARZENEGGER,SIGNED,THE YEAR,PASS,TWO THIRDS VOTE,APPELLATE COURT,FINDINGS,GLOBAL WARMING,THREAT,ECONOMIC,WELL BEING,PUBLIC,NATURAL RESOURCES,ENVIRONMENT OF CALIFORNIA,DETRIMENTAL,CALIFORNIAS,LARGEST,INDUSTRIES,AGENCY,MONITORING,SOURCES,GREENHOUSE GASES,CAUSE,GLOBAL WARMING IN,ORDER,DESIGNATION,INTENTION,MEET,LIMITS,MANNER,COSTS,BENEFITS,ECONOMY,IMPROVES,ENERGY INFRASTRUCTURE,ELECTRIC SYSTEM,IMPROVE,DIRECTIVES,THINGS,REPORTING,LIMIT,EQUIVALENT,LEVEL,RULES,MAXIMUM,TECHNOLOGICALLY,COST EFFECTIVE,EMISSION,REDUCTIONS,FORTH,DISCRETE,EARLY ACTION,GHG EMISSION,REDUCTION,CHILDRENS,EARTH,FOUNDATION,RESOURCES,CAL APP,PROMULGATED,CAP AND TRADE SYSTEM,AUCTION,COMPONENT,17 SS,ASSOCIATION OF,IRRITATED,FN 6,PURPOSE,IDENTIFIED,ARTICLE,THE ESTABLISHMENT,ADMINISTRATION,AGGREGATE,ALLOWANCE,BUDGET,TRADING,MECHANISM,THRESHOLD,POINT,THE OPEN,MARKET,PRICE,CONTAINMENT,RESERVE,BUFFER,HIGH,PRICES,THE REST,PERIOD,CREATES,CARBON,MANUFACTURING,PRODUCTION,UTILITY,OPERATIONS,EMIT,REGULATORY SYSTEM,EFFECTIVE,GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS,REGULATION,THE PROGRAM,BROAD SPECTRUM,ELECTRICITY,NATURAL GAS,FUEL,SUPPLIERS,WHOM,PREVIOUSLY,REPORTED,THE ANNUAL,LOWERED,OVER TIME,LIMITED,NUMBER,TOTAL,EQUAL TO,ID SS,AUTHORIZATION,UP TO,METRIC,CARBON DIOXIDE EQUIVALENT,CO2E,IBID,TIMELY,OBLIGATION,RELEVANT,CALCULATED,FORMULA,LIMITATIONS,MEANS,BUY,BANK,SELL,SATISFY,OFFSETS,PERCENTAGE,SUPRA,CRAFTING,FOLLOW,NINE,STATUTORY,GUIDELINES,EXTENT,ATTEMPT,MAXIMIZE,ENCOURAGE,DISPROPORTIONATE,IMPACT,INCOME,COMMUNITIES,CREDIT,COMPLEMENT,EXISTING,FEDERAL AND STATE,STANDARDS,CONSIDER,COST EFFECTIVENESS,OVERALL,SOCIETAL,IMPLEMENTATION,LEAKAGE,C,THE SIGNIFICANCE OF,CONTRIBUTION,CATEGORY,DEFINES,DECLINING,ANNUAL,CATEGORIES OF,BANKING,TRANSACTIONS,GOVERNED,PROTOCOLS,SAME TIME,DIRECT,MEASURE,DIVISION,DECREASE,IN THEORY,SHOULD,INCREASE,MONEY,THE LIFE,PLANS,HALF,CITING,MATERIALS,REQUEST,JUDICIAL NOTICE,DISPUTE,AS OF,JANUARY 1,THE PRICE,RO